With the rapid and almost surprising rise of content curation or “social bookmarking 3.0″ site Pinterest, we wanted to take a deeper look into just how men and women curate their digital content. This represented a challenge, as we don’t use surveys to ask these kinds of questions, we passively collect and analyse information and turn it into “intelligence” – you see, it’s intelligence we use to make decisions, not information (as stated by JFK.) The methodology we used is below if you’re interested. Our sample size was 250 men and 250 women; treated as blinds in aggregate, no personal information was collected/analysed.
Women & Content Curation in Social Media
Women are “gatherers” and to some degree “hoarders” of digital content. But while they collect more content online, they are also more organised with their content and tend to share across a broader network. Women also collect more text content than men, such as blog posts. Women discuss societal issues (laws, education and healthcare etc.) about 20% more than men. Men, however, discuss politics 24% more than women. Women “tag” content more than men as well; part of their being better organised on content curation. When it comes to discussing technology such as apps or devices, women will focus on the benefits.
Men & Content Curation in Social Media
Men are haphazard collectors of content. They prefer video and images and rarely tend to share text information. Men don’t collect and organise content as much as women either. There is also a tendency to “one-up” each other in groups by sharing content that would be seen as being “better”, as in funnier or more interesting than the last piece of content shared. Men also tend to share “humorous” content more than any other kind, preferably video format. For men when it comes to discussing technology such as as apps or devices, they will debate the features over the benefits, including price. Men also share less across networks they aren’t as familiar with, whereas women are more open and social in new apps.
As we’ve seen in general trend analysis, the preferred forms of content to be created and shared and also curated it turns out, is video and images. Text is still common, but less of it. We’ve seen the average blog post dwindle from 800 words in 2009 down to less than 300 in 2012. Both men and women prefer video and image. And when it comes to ranting or opinion-making on news sites, we see both men and women almost equally sharing their views. Both men and women tend to curate more content on sites that are easiest to use, such as Pinterest or Storify, perhaps in part explaining their success. We also found that women would recommend an online app or tool 40% more often than men. But men would recommend technology devices more than women by 15%.
For apps designers and developers – keep thinking ease of use. For marketers, women remain in Cyburbia as they tend to in the real-world, the best networkers and the ideal target to drive popularity of general consumer apps and products. Women return to and keep content (in social bookmarking sites, social networks etc.) more than men and are far more organised overall.
To do this, we looked the profiles of 250 men and 250 women who had active (engaging in each platform at least three times per week) publicly available profiles in sites such as Pinterest, Gentlemint, Delicious, Google+, Storify, Cowbird and Twitter. We also looked at 50 open Facebook groups where 25 had predominantly male membership and 25 with predominantly female members (over 98%.) We then ensured they were within the age bracket of 30-45 using our methodology for doing this (which is proprietary to us but has a 87% accuracy rate.) We also ensured a cultural distribution across Caucasian, African American/Canadian and Asian ethnic groups. Profiles were random across the United States, UK and Canada. We did not collect any information from profiles that were not publicly available. We do not collect names or locations of test profiles, no such data is retained on our servers at any time. Names may be reviewed as part of gender validation only, but are not kept or stored in any form after analysis and verification. None of the information is re-sold to a third party unless it is in aggregate form.
Posted By: Davis for the team which included almost all of us and a lot of debate and statistical fights in which the CEO often left to get “coffee”….